Review: ‘Schmigadoon!’ Has a Song in Its Heart, and Everywhere Else

Welcome to Schmigadoon, “where the men are men, and the cows are cows,” a magical musical land the place Melissa and Josh (Cecily Strong and Keegan-Michael Key) discover themselves stranded throughout a journey meant to rehabilitate their romance. At first they suppose it’s like Colonial Williamsburg, or a warped Disney expertise, however they shortly purchase into their new actuality: They’re trapped in this healthful, old-timey parallel universe till they be taught the teachings about true adore it is supposed to impart.

Melissa is into it. She likes musicals, and she’s thrilled to find that when she joins in on one of many townsfolk’s numbers, she instinctively is aware of what to sing. Josh shouldn’t be into it. He dislikes musicals, and he refuses to sing alongside. She desires to be in love, get married and win each argument. He desires her to just accept that love is flawed and marriage is no matter, and he additionally desires to win each argument.

I received’t say that there are solely two kinds of folks with regards to musicals, however for our functions: The Joshes of the world are unlikely ever to heat to “Schmigadoon!” To my fellow Melissas: Dust off your character footwear. Our time is now.

“Schmigadoon!,” which debuts on Apple TV+ Friday, was created by Ken Daurio and Cinco Paul, the crew behind the “Despicable Me” franchise; Paul additionally wrote all of the songs. The present’s most blatant references are “Brigadoon,” “Carousel” and “Oklahoma!” But there’s additionally loads of “Annie Get Your Gun” in there, in addition to “Seven Brides for Seven Brothers,” “The Music Man,” “The Sound of Music,” “South Pacific” and “The King and I.” Individual numbers have nods to dozens of different musicals. Some are direct parodies of particular songs — Melissa explains human copy in medical element in a spoof of “Do-Re-Mi” — and others ship up the style in basic.

The residents of Schmigadoon are additionally strolling parodies. Kristin Chenoweth is the city grouch and principal villain, a darkish lipstick nightmare who turns to her fellow tut-tutters and asks, “Ladies, can I get a cackle?” Alan Cumming is her husband and the closeted mayor. Jaime Camil is the sultry, judgmental physician, Aaron Tveit is the hunky dangerous boy in “Carousel” cable knit, and Ariana DeBose is the enchanting college marm. Tveit and DeBose are significantly electrical, and when they’re singing — and even higher, singing and dancing — it’s unattainable to not root for them. Everyone, go forth and win the hearts of our depressing normies.

Cecily Strong and Keegan-Michael Key play characters with diverging concepts about marriage and musicals.Credit…Apple TV+, through Associated Press

“Schmigadoon!” has its moments of excellent sincere enjoyable, however it’s extra inclined towards ironic and satirical enjoyable — it’s in by itself joke and routinely mocks its personal corniness. (There’s even a track referred to as “Corn Puddin’,” which, like all the opposite songs on the present, is fairly darn good.) The vibe works, significantly the jabs at traditional musicals’ inflexible sexism. The present’s credited writers, Bowen Yang, Julie Klausner, Allison Silverman and Kate Gersten, are finest identified for his or her work in sketch comedy and sitcoms, so unsurprisingly the punch traces are intelligent and typically acidic. But it does typically really feel as if “Schmigadoon!” had just one actual joke: Musicals, particularly these of the ’40s and ’50s, are just like each other, and tacky.

We love these musicals not in spite of these qualities however due to them, and “Schmigadoon!” embodies why whimsy will be so interesting. The extra the collection focuses on Melissa and Josh’s conflicts, significantly on Josh’s bitter avoidance, the extra one longs for goofy elation and purposeless guffawing. Sure, the city is prim and smothering, however wouldn’t you relatively dance your troubles away than return to that pile of tedious self-help books about the right way to save a lukewarm relationship?

Naïveté will be a vice, however so can obstinance. Is falling in love over a trumpet actually dumber than every other manner folks fall in love? Isn’t it good to sing what you’ll be able to’t say, particularly when you’ll be able to’t appear to say a lot in any respect?

“Nobody likes a dream ballet,” Melissa declares close to the tip of the season, a line that thrilled me as a result of I certainly was softly dreading what appeared to be the onset of precisely such a second. Dream ballets are usually not my favourite anyway, however “Schmigadoon!” would have collapsed beneath the burden of 1 as a result of for all its ample joys and glories, it isn’t constructed like a two-act musical. It’s constructed as a six-episode TV present. So it might’t generate momentum in the identical methods, can’t breathe in and out, can’t orient itself towards an 11 o’clock quantity. Hooray for an overture, however should you binge the present, you hear that overture six occasions, at which level it’s simply a theme track. (Apple TV+ is releasing the primary two episodes collectively, and the next 4 episodes weekly after that.)

This provides as much as a slight however persistent sense of not-quite-rightness, echoing Melissa’s and Josh’s emotions of being in the incorrect story. It’s a present whose personal protagonist complains, “It’s like if ‘The Walking Dead’ was also ‘Glee.’” (I feel it’s extra like “Smash” or “Gallivant,” as a result of its songs are all unique, however I doubt Josh would know what “Smash” or “Gallivant” are.)

At occasions, “Schmigadoon!” can really feel like a “Simpsons” parody that outgrew its phase, or a traditional film butchered in order to insert industrial breaks. Luckily, it’s additionally too enjoyable for many of that to matter.