Opinion | The N.Y.C. Subways Have a Crime Problem

Roughly three.9 million folks entered Manhattan beneath 60th Street each weekday lately till March of 2020. Most of those folks had ridden the subway into city: They flooded up from underground and streamed into workplaces and eating places and retail shops, to Broadway theaters and Times Square and the Empire State Building. They made Midtown and Lower Manhattan the anchor of jobs and wealth within the Northeast.

Sixteen months after New York’s lockdown, nonetheless, foot visitors in Midtown resembles that on a sleepy Sunday. So lots of the metropolis’s highest-paid employees are nonetheless working at dwelling full time, conserving workplaces in central elements of town largely empty when in comparison with their prepandemic ranges.

But we have to confront a root obstacle to New York’s coming absolutely again to life, one seen in Chicago, Philadelphia and another cities, too: concern of the subways. Before the pandemic, three-quarters of every day guests to Midtown and Lower Manhattan got here in through transit, greater than 2.2 million on the subway. Today, weekday subway ridership stays lower than half of regular.

Potential subway riders could concern Covid, however additionally they concern crime and harassment, in response to the Metropolitan Transportation Authority. In the primary quarter of this 12 months, solely 26 p.c of riders felt glad with the degrees of crime and harassment on trains, down from 65 p.c within the remaining quarter of 2019. In stations, 34 p.c of riders have been glad with the speed of crime and harassment, down from round 70 p.c.

New Yorkers haven’t had a lot cause to fret about public security on the subways because the 1990s. But if New York is to be New York once more, it’s a drawback that Eric Adams, probably town’s subsequent mayor, goes to have to unravel.

For Mr. Adams, the answer needs to be clear. As a former Transit Police officer, he is aware of it effectively. The metropolis wants to extend the extent of police enforcement in opposition to smaller crimes within the subways. Doing so will make folks comfy sufficient to make use of transit to return to workplace jobs and different actions. Given the posture of many progressive leaders within the metropolis towards the police, this can be a take a look at for Mr. Adams, however it’s one town wants him to fulfill.

A brand new evaluation of subway and police knowledge that I created for the Manhattan Institute reveals why town must counter the specter of crime and harassment in opposition to potential riders. Between January 2020 and May of this 12 months, 10 folks misplaced their lives to murder on the subways. Since the late 1990s, the typical variety of killings on the subways has been one to 2 yearly. In little greater than a 12 months, New York has skilled 5 years’ price of homicides.

Crime underground continues to be uncommon. But it’s much less uncommon than it was earlier than. Moreover, the character of those crimes introduces an added anxiousness. In distinction to violent crime above floor, crime within the subways seems to be virtually all the time stranger-on-stranger.

Random pushings and different assaults are, by their nature, onerous to foretell and thus onerous to guard in opposition to. Of the 5 folks arrested for six of the 10 subway killings since March 2020, not one of the suspects appeared to know their sufferer.

Other felonies, too, have elevated on New York subways. In 2020, there have been 2.71 felonies dedicated per million rides, up from 1.45 in 2019. Most disturbing, although, is the elevated danger of violent felonies in opposition to folks versus property.

My evaluation for the Manhattan Institute discovered that violent felonies — homicide, rape, theft and assault — have elevated disproportionately in contrast with nonviolent property crime. During 2020, regardless of severely diminished ridership, violent crime rose to 928 incidents from 917 the 12 months earlier than.

Though the state of affairs has improved since then, it’s removed from regular. According to my evaluation, any single rider faces better danger of changing into a sufferer of a violent felony, versus a property-theft felony. In 2021 by June, at a mean of 1.5 cases of bodily hurt per million rides, the bodily menace was 3 times the prepandemic common.

What can we do to fight crime on the subways?

Crowds assist, however they aren’t the one preventive pressure accessible. In 1990 in New York, there have been 26 homicides on the subway and 18,324 felonies total. In the wake of those statistics, the transit police underneath Bill Bratton sought to cease folks from committing small crimes — fare-beating amongst them — hoping it might forestall them from committing worse crimes.

Over the previous 5 years, the police have eased such enforcement. That’s to riders’ detriment, on condition that this type of enforcement nonetheless works. Of the 779 arrests that the police made within the subway system in January and February 2021, 51 of the folks, or 6.6 p.c, have been alleged to be carrying weapons or knives.

Today, the issue is that such a enforcement has fallen with diminished ridership. In the years earlier than the pandemic, even because the police eased the enforcement described above, crime remained low. This was, partially, due to near-record subway crowds. But now the crowds are gone, and security in numbers has disappeared. The police should step again up.

In his total reform of the Police Department, Mr. Adams ought to employees the transit system with extra police to make up for the decrease civilian foot visitors. He must also encourage law enforcement officials to interact respectfully and with minimal pressure with suspected fare-beaters and different low-level transgressors. A overwhelming majority of enforcement for such nonviolent offenses ought to proceed to be civil fines, not felony fees. And town should clarify, by higher reporting, that it’ll not tolerate racial discrimination in such enforcement.

But New York can not look forward to ridership to return up, fixing the issue naturally. It is kind of potential that subway ridership will keep at depressed ranges for years, with smaller crowds encouraging crime, and crime, in flip, discouraging greater crowds.

Fear of the subways partly outlined New York within the 1970s and ’80s. Mr. Adams can be judged partially by whether or not folks really feel protected — and are protected — on the rails.

Nicole Gelinas is a contributing editor to the Manhattan Institute’s City Journal. She is at work on a e book about New York City’s fashionable transportation historical past.

The Times is dedicated to publishing a range of letters to the editor. We’d like to listen to what you concentrate on this or any of our articles. Here are some suggestions. And right here’s our e-mail: [email protected]

Follow The New York Times Opinion part on Facebook, Twitter (@NYTopinion) and Instagram.