‘Broken Diamonds’ Review: Illness as a Narrative Convenience

The drama “Broken Diamonds” begins with the demise of a household patriarch and the reunion of distant siblings. Scott (Ben Platt) is a author hoping to flee to a profession in Paris, however when his father dies, he’s compelled into the function of caregiver for his older sister, Cindy (Lola Kirke). She started displaying signs of schizophrenia when she and Scott have been youngsters, and as an grownup, she resides at a care facility that intends to expel her for poor conduct. Cindy is launched to dwell with Scott, however his impatience in his function makes it more durable for her to take care of stability.

This movie dramatizes the impact that psychological sickness has on households, however sadly its portrait of Cindy’s life with schizophrenia by no means transcends cliché. A problem of crafting a story round sickness, psychological or in any other case, is that in life, flare-ups are neither ethical nor fully predictable. The director, Peter Sattler, emphasizes the uncontrollable nature of Cindy’s sickness as a plot level, however the narrative comfort of her psychological state is clear in each gesture, each line of dialogue and each motion of the digital camera.

Cindy’s highs and lows correspond immediately with Scott’s conduct, his character’s want for development. When she experiences a disaster, the breakdown maps predictably into climactic story beats. The film treats sickness as a collection of contrivances, an engine that retains the plot pistoning ahead, and the results of this method is a movie that feels lifeless, or worse, reductive. It mines drama from a dysfunction, and gives no perception, no magnificence, no humor in return.

Broken Diamonds
Rated PG-13 for references to self-harm and language. Running time: 1 hour and 30 minutes. In theaters and out there to hire or purchase on FandangoNow, Google Play and different streaming platforms and pay TV operators.