Venice Film Festival: ‘Dune’ Leaves Us With 3 Big Questions

The spice should circulation. But will audiences go?

Denis Villeneuve’s extremely anticipated “Dune” premiered Friday on the Venice Film Festival, an uncommon place to debut a sci-fi franchise-starter that price upward of $160 million. Then once more, “Dune” isn’t your typical tentpole.

It’s one thing dreamier and weirder, a film that straddles the road between auteurist art-film and studio blockbuster so provocatively that even after watching it, I can’t fairly predict how “Dune” will fare when it comes out in theaters (and on HBO Max) on Oct. 22. When I left my screening, the primary critic I spoke to was completely besotted. The second fled the theater as if Villeneuve had planted a bomb there.

Still, after a decade of Marvel films made with high-level craftsmanship however few formal dangers, it’s bracing to get a film of this scale that takes such huge creative swings. Here are three questions that stored swimming round in my head after watching it.

Can ‘Dune’ grow to be a big-screen hit?

Though “Dune” relies on a basic sci-fi novel by Frank Herbert, diversifications of it have hardly set the world on fireplace. David Lynch’s 1984 adaptation was a well-known catastrophe that the director disavowed, whereas two mini-series diversifications have been extra notable for stuffing wonky blue contact lenses into the eyes of a younger James McAvoy than for uplifting any important pop-cultural response.

But “Dune” has sturdy bones, and so they’ve been picked over significantly since Herbert’s novel was printed in 1965. So many movies have been impressed by “Dune” that the contours of the story would possibly really feel acquainted now: A younger man (Timothée Chalamet) is distributed to an unique planet that’s being mined for a beneficial pure useful resource — on this case, the hallucinogenic “spice” — however he finally decides to throw in his lot with the Indigenous folks and struggle again towards their well-militarized oppressors.

Yes, that’s principally the identical plot as “Avatar” … and hey, perhaps that’s factor! After all, “Avatar” was a record-setting blockbuster, and whereas Chalamet is new to main this sort of film, Villeneuve has surrounded him with a forged of veterans: Jason Momoa, Dave Bautista and Josh Brolin have all accomplished their time within the superhero salt mines, Oscar Isaac is contemporary off a “Star Wars” trilogy, and Rebecca Ferguson has grow to be the main woman of the “Mission: Impossible” franchise. If so many different tentpole movies have stolen from “Dune,” the least “Dune” might do is steal one thing again.

Still, even with that pedigree, “Dune” faces some important obstacles. The movie completed principal images over two years in the past and was initially set for launch in November 2020 till Warner Bros. determined to delay the movie for almost a yr. The expectation was that the push would place “Dune” in a post-Covid movie panorama; the fact is that the persevering with havoc wreaked by the Delta variant has film studios spooked sufficient to shove some main films (like “Top Gun: Maverick”) into 2022.

In some methods, this might be factor for “Dune”: With fewer brand-driven blockbusters within the market, “Dune” might stand out and draw curious viewers who’re longing for one thing huge to observe. But to Villeneuve’s vocal consternation, the movie may also premiere on HBO Max on the identical time it bows in theaters, which might reduce into box-office receipts and threaten the chances that a sequel will likely be greenlit.

It might have an effect on the primary spherical of buzz, too: The viewers that can go see “Dune” in theaters is extra inclined to be invested in it (and can expertise its visible and sonic pleasures on the largest potential scale), whereas the bored, curious and unfamiliar who click on over on HBO Max will not be as keen on Villeneuve’s mise en scène. The first important motion sequence, a sandworm assault, doesn’t arrive till an hour into the film. Are at-home audiences going to be as prepared to see issues by way of because the individuals who eagerly paid for their very own tickets?

Timothée Chalamet and Rebecca Ferguson in a scene from “Dune.”Credit…Chiabella James/Warner Bros.

Will ‘Dune’ be a significant Oscar participant?

Part of what’s so placing about “Dune” is that Villeneuve has a way of texture that’s uncommon amongst big-budget filmmakers. When a personality falls in battle, Villeneuve is besotted with the best way the person’s eyelashes flutter as he dies. And through the assault on a personality’s compound, the digital camera drifts from the motion to indicate us magnificent palm bushes which have been set aflame, their leafy crowns now a starburst of destruction.

Though sci-fi films can typically be a tough promote with Oscar voters, I believe that Villeneuve’s distinctive eye will distinguish “Dune,” because the film appears undeniably ravishing. A ton of below-the-line nominations are assured, together with Greig Fraser’s cinematography and the manufacturing design by Patrice Vermette. The rating (by Hans Zimmer), sound and modifying are all extra daring than this style normally permits: The aural soundscape and artsy crosscutting really feel virtually designed to attract you right into a spice-induced trance.

And I haven’t even gotten to the style! The costume design (by Jacqueline West and Bob Morgan) is a stunner, and particularly through the first hour of the movie — with Rebecca Ferguson carrying outrageous space-nun sheaths and a veiled Charlotte Rampling dressed just like the Green Knight in Gaultier — “Dune” can seem to be a moody high-fashion shoot that often consists of spaceships. (I imply this as factor.)

Villeneuve’s final movie, “Blade Runner 2049,” scored 5 Oscar nominations and received its cinematographer Roger Deakins a long-overdue Academy Award. Still, the film couldn’t break into the 2 prime Oscar classes, finest image and finest director. Does “Dune” stand a greater probability?

I’m taking the wait-and-see strategy right here. None of the actors from “Dune” are prone to be nominated, which might have helped legitimize a movie like this with Oscar voters, and an adapted-screenplay nomination isn’t a foregone conclusion, both. Still, after 2020’s intimate discipline, I feel the academy is raring to get a much bigger film into the best-picture race. Villeneuve’s struggle to get his film seen on the massive display screen may resonate with streaming-skeptical voters who see his stubbornness as a campaign price backing.

The director Denis Villeneuve, middle, in Venice surrounded by his “Dune” forged: from left, Javier Bardem, Zendaya, Rebecca Ferguson, Timothée Chalamet, Oscar Isaac and Josh Brolin.Credit…Yara Nardi/Reuters

Is ‘Dune: Part Two’ a positive factor?

Viewers who watch “Dune” anticipating an entire expertise could also be thrown for a loop when the title card comes up: This isn’t “Dune,” it’s “Dune: Part One.”

Villeneuve has cut up Herbert’s guide roughly in half, that means that a number of of the numerous character arcs are simply getting began when this movie involves an in depth. And although Zendaya is plastered all around the advertising as the feminine lead, it’s actually Ferguson who will get that highlight: Outside of some dreamy visions of what’s to come back, Zendaya’s character doesn’t issue into the story in a giant method simply but.

Villeneuve intends to make “Dune” a two-parter and is engaged on the screenplay for the sequel, however Warner Bros. nonetheless hasn’t technically greenlit it. The studio has tried the two-film gambit earlier than, splitting the Stephen King adaptation “It” into halves, however these movies opened two years aside and a potential “Dune” sequel would doubtless take far longer to mount. (It may concern the studio that “It Chapter Two” made some $225 million much less worldwide than the primary movie, regardless of an inflow of huge stars.)

Perhaps Warner Bros. is taking a wait-and-see strategy, too, and watching the “Dune” field workplace earlier than pulling the set off on a second movie, however the benchmarks of success look very completely different throughout a pandemic and a simultaneous streaming run. With a deliberate HBO Max spinoff collection targeted on the Bene Gesserit (a secretive, all-female group that counts Ferguson’s and Rampling’s characters amongst its acolytes), I’m stunned that the studio received’t firmly decide to a sequel now, if solely to engineer some momentum forward of the movie’s launch.

It would additionally cue audiences to anticipate an unfinished story on the finish of “Dune,” which rockets by way of a few higher-octane climaxes earlier than touchdown on a considerably muted denouement. Villeneuve does loads of teasing: Many main occasions to come back are glimpsed, as if the film can’t wait to get to the great things. But how lengthy a wait will that show to be?