House Hunting: Is This Price Right?

Kim Rohrer was trying ahead to leaving the leaky home windows within the two-bedroom Berkeley rental duplex that she shared along with her husband and two young children.

The couple just lately discovered a three-bedroom, two-bathroom chalet-style home in Berkeley listed for $799,000, which appeared comparatively reasonably priced for the world.

The home wanted important work, together with plumbing upgrades, however the couple wasn’t deterred. “It was like a dream house,” stated Ms. Rohrer, who works in human sources for a tech firm. (Her husband works on the University of California, Berkeley.)

The couple provided effectively above the asking worth: $850,000. They knew there would doubtless be a number of affords however additionally they wanted to avoid wasting cash for the mandatory repairs. They didn’t get the home.

They didn’t even come shut. The residence bought for $1.four million — practically double its asking worth. “It’s terrible,” she says of her home searching expertise thus far. “Completely terrible.”

As the housing market roared again to life within the United States this previous spring, with demand far outpacing the obtainable provide of houses, the brand new regular has come to incorporate open homes with traces out the door, bidding wars and houses promoting for effectively over asking worth. According to knowledge from, 37 p.c of houses now promote for over the asking worth — up from 13 p.c in 2018. The typical purchaser pays about $2,200 over the asking worth, or zero.6 p.c, in line with, based mostly on a median record worth nationwide of $367,000.

But nowhere else in America do houses promote for extra over asking worth than in Berkeley, Calif., the place roughly 80 p.c of houses promote above the listed worth, in line with Zillow. In neighboring Oakland, it’s simply over 70 p.c of houses. Berkeley additionally has the very best overbid scenario within the nation, in line with, with listings promoting for a mean of 19 p.c over asking. In Oakland, the everyday home goes for 11.2 p.c above asking. Many, just like the one Ms. Rohrer put a suggestion on go for a lot, way more — generally $1 million or extra.

Daniel Stea, of Stea Realty Group, which has workplaces in Oakland and Berkeley, just lately listed a house in Rockridge, a neighborhood on the border of Oakland and Berkeley identified for its charming Craftsman houses and fast BART commute into San Francisco. The home, a 2,400-square-foot, four-bedroom brown-shingle Craftsman, has a big, renovated kitchen and an enormous yard with a indifferent workplace studio. Mr. Stea listed it for $1.795 million. It bought in August for $three.zero75 million.

Homes typically promote for a lot greater than their listed worth within the Bay Area as a result of brokers deliberately underprice listings to drum up as many affords as potential. Mr. Stea stated that whereas he was shocked the Rockridge residence went for as a lot because it did, he knew it might go for effectively above the asking worth. “I’m a true believer in that the market will always tell the truth,” he stated.

The technique is to create one thing of a blind public sale the place patrons attempt to puzzle out a quantity that the sellers’ will truly settle for and a quantity that’s increased than all the opposite affords. It’s a neighborhood quirk that everybody appears to acknowledge is simply the way in which that issues are executed right here.

Jodi Nishimura, a Compass agent based mostly in Oakland, stated she was shocked when she moved to the world from New York in 2002 and noticed how listings had been priced decrease than their price, normally round 10 p.c much less at the moment. “It wasn’t common to see homes go for 50 percent over the listing,” she stated. The Covid housing growth has made issues worse, she stated, with sure houses — significantly ones with nice outside area — promoting for big premiums, effectively above their listed costs.

Buyers are likely to detest the underpricing — describing it as every part from “a sick game” to “bizarre.” But brokers say it really works effectively for sellers. “Sellers want to keep the bidding war blind,” stated Mr. Stea, who had the Rockridge home that bought for greater than $1 million over asking. “But it disfavors buyers because they’re shooting in the dark.”

D.J. Grubb, president of the Grubb Company, a neighborhood brokerage, additionally attributed the acute discrepancy between record costs and sale costs to a fast-moving market the place residence values have climbed shortly, making it tough to precisely determine the worth of houses.

Agents within the space use a traditional “merchandising strategy,” however take it to an excessive, says Mr. Grubb. Instead of utilizing the retail trick of pricing a $1 million product at $999,000, brokers within the space sometimes advise sellers to cost a $1 million residence to seize patrons purchasing within the $750,000 worth vary, which suggests a listing worth of $749,000. That approach, a number of affords will are available in with the successful bid sometimes round $1 million. If sufficient affords are available in, one would possibly are available in at $1.2 million — perhaps from somebody keen to pay a premium to place an finish their exhausting housing search, or somebody who assumes residence values will quickly rise to fulfill what they’ve paid.

When Katy Anderson purchased her Upper Rockridge residence about 10 years in the past, she and her husband reworked it from prime to backside, together with eradicating a swimming pool to create a big, flat garden her kids used as a soccer discipline. Ms. Anderson stated they had been able to “cash out” and purchase a fixer higher in Orinda, a close-by suburb, and pocket a few of the fairness as a monetary cushion.

Ms. Anderson, who can be an actual property agent with Compass, paid $786,000 for the house a decade in the past and spent about $500,000 on the transform. She thought they could be capable to get above $2 million for the three,000-square-foot residence — then she noticed a neighboring residence promote for $2.6 million.

But that didn’t imply she was going to cost it wherever near that. “You can never price a home too low, or that’s sort of the theory,” she stated. With some nudging from her agent companion, Katie Krembs, she listed her residence for $1.795 million, which she admits made her nervous on the time, because it was far lower than it was price. “But at the end of the day, which area of the store gets more attention? It’s always the sale rack,” she stated. “The goal of the Realtor is always to get as many eyes as possible on the house.”

Rafael Reis, Will Dogan and their 2-year-old daughter just lately moved again to the Bay Area from Denver. Mr. Dogan stated they discovered the shopping for course of “hard and weird and super stressful.”Credit…Jim Wilson/The New York Times

The residence obtained 21 affords, together with one from Will Dogan and Rafael Reis, who had been searching for a house so they may relocate again to the Bay Area after dwelling in Denver for three and a half years for work.

Mr. Dogan, who has a 2-year-old daughter, stated Ms. Anderson’s residence had been “spruced up nicely,” and he appreciated that it had an enormous flat yard. His actual property agent stated the proprietor was most likely hoping for affords effectively above the asking worth, so Mr. Dogan and Mr. Reis provided $2.75 million. They didn’t get the home.

“It was really hard and weird and super stressful,” Mr. Dogan stated of the method, which concerned circling again with the highest bidders for counter affords. “In Denver, if you see a home you like, you just make an offer,” he stated. “It’s a pretty straight forward process.”

Ultimately, Ms. Anderson’s home bought for $three.05 million — or greater than 70 p.c over the asking worth. Ms. Anderson stated a number of of the affords had been near the ultimate sale worth and so they merely selected the very best provide, which exceeded her wildest expectations. “$3.05 million is crazy,” she stated.

Mr. Dogan ended up discovering one other home, within the Berkeley Hills. The property had “only” three different affords and he secured the successful bid with $2.65 million, or 30 p.c over asking. He additionally agreed to waive all contingencies, together with financing and inspection.

Ms. Anderson, who benefited from the underpricing technique as a vendor, stated she had combined emotions about it basically and is aware of “buyers are sick of it.” For brokers, it may be exhausting as a result of it means the method consists of a variety of disappointment for individuals who lose out on houses. But it will probably additionally make the function of an agent extra essential, as patrons making an attempt to deal with hunt on their very own may not be clued into what any specific itemizing is definitely price.

“It’s a conundrum in the whole industry right now,” she stated. “It feels like you’re duping people into making offers.” And but, “the results speak for themselves,” she added.

Becky Koch discovered a house in Oakland that was priced near its true market worth — which her agent advised her had confused different patrons. “You really do have to learn to play the game,” stated Ms. Koch, pictured right here along with her 9-month-old child.Credit…Jim Wilson/The New York Times

Becky Koch just lately bought her first home in Rockridge after making seven bids on different properties, together with one which had 30 affords and bought to an all-cash purchaser.

Ms. Koch, who works for a know-how firm, and her husband, an assistant principal, determined to alter their search parameters to incorporate solely houses that had been available on the market for 20 days or extra, longer than the everyday two weeks. Their pondering was that these houses may be those they’d the perfect shot at as a result of they’d obtained the fewest affords. They discovered a three-bedroom residence in Rockridge priced at $1.185 million, which gave the impression to be within the ballpark of the house’s true market worth based mostly on comparable houses that had bought just lately within the space. Her dealer advised her the “transparent” pricing had confused patrons and left the sellers with no rapid affords.

The vendor then lowered the worth to $895,000, which Ms. Koch stated she thought most likely confused patrons even additional.

They received the home with a $1.2 million provide and moved in a pair months in the past with their 9-month previous child. “You really do have to learn to play the game,” she stated.

Sneha Madiath has been in search of the previous six months in Oakland and Berkeley with a funds of $1.5 million and providing as a lot as 30 p.c over asking. One home had a list worth of $900,000 and bought for $2.three million. “You don’t know whether you should bid 20 percent over the asking price? Fifty percent over? Double it?” she stated. “I feel like I’m in a John Malkovich movie.”

For weekly e mail updates on residential actual property information, join right here. Follow us on Twitter: @nytrealestate.